I promised myself I wouldn't buy either of these...until I saw them 40% off at Jewel. Apparently I can pass them up at $1.99 but at $1.19 I couldn't. Leave it to me to not pass something up 80cents cheaper. I purchased Black Magic and Purple Potion. Neither of them are very exciting or interesting the cute tombstone bottles sure make up for it! PP is a purple glitter in a black base and BM is just a typical black with silver glitter in it.